Outstanding performances

Since 1976, the All-Star Football Classic has showcased the best high school talent in Western New York. These records represent the standout performances and lasting legacies from over four decades of All-Star competition.

Boy's Games

1976-2025

Girl's Games

2023-2025

Individual Records

Please turn your device to landscape orientation to see this chart.

Record

Player

School

Year

Team

Most Passes Attempted
Most Passes Completed
Most Passing Yardage
Most Touchdown Passes
Most Passes Caught
Most Pass Receiving Yardage
Longest Pass Play
Longest Pass Play for TD
Most Interceptions
Longest Interception for TD
Most Carries
Most Rushing Yardage
Longest Run from Scrimmage
Longest Run from Scrimmage
Longest Run from Scrimmage
Longest Kickoff Return for TD
Longest Kickoff Return for TD
Most Points Scored
Most Touchdowns
Longest Field Goal
Longest Punt
Highest Punt Average
Longest Punt Return
Most PAT by Kick
Most PAT by Kick
Most PAT by Run or Pass

37
22
343
5
10
140
79
75
4
86
26
177
78
78
78
85
85
24
4
47
65
53.7
86
5
5
2

attempts
completions
yards
touchdowns
receptions
yards
yards
yards
interceptions
yards
carries
yards
yards
yards
yards
yards
yards
points
touchdowns
yards
yards
yards
yards
PATs
PATs
PATs

Andy Smigiera
Andy Smigiera
Andy Smigiera
Andy Smigiera
Mark Pollard
Mark Pollard
M. Moscato to M. Donovan
E. Rusin to E. Lewis
Tom Feeney
Adam Redden
Ron Wolfley
Darren Thompson
Jordan Johnson
Jason Burch
Darren Thompson
Joe Puntoriero
Todd Burks
Todd Burks
Todd Burks
Mark Menchetti
Joe Blahowicz
Adam Fatzinger
Jacob Graci
Tom Gioia
Sean Seefeldt
Terrell Moore

West Seneca East
West Seneca East
West Seneca East
West Seneca East
Tonawanda
Tonawanda
O.P. to Iroquois
Amherst to Will. E.
Grand Island
St. Francis
Frontier
St. Joes
Sweet Home
Southwestern
St. Joes
Depew
Clarence
Clarence
Clarence
Kenmore East
Alden
Williamsville North
Lake Shore
Timon-St. Jude
Newfane
South Park

2013
2013
2013
2013
1979
1979
1991
1995
1992
2010
1981
2016
2012
2000
2016
1979
1989
1989
1989
2001
2002
2001
2005
2013
2012
2000

South
South
South
South
North
North
South
North
North
South
South
North
North
South
North
South
North
North
North
North
South
North
South
South
North
South

Team and Game Records

Please turn your device to landscape orientation to see this chart.

Record

Team/ Game

Year

Most First Downs
Least First Downs
Most First Downs
Least First Downs
Most Passes Attempted
Most Passes Attempted
Most Passes Completed
Most Passing Yardage
Least Passing Yardage
Most Points Scored
Most Points Scored
Most Total Yards
Least Total Yards
Most Punts
Most Punts
Most Punts
Most Kickoffs
Most Punts
Most Penalty Yards
Most Penalties Called Against
Most Plays
Most Total Plays
Most Total Yards
Most Fumbles
Most Turnovers
Most Points Scored
Most Passes Intercepted Thrown
Least Points Scored
Most Carries
Most Points in One Half
Most Rushing Yardage
Most Points in One Quarter
Least Rushing Yardage
Most Offensive Plays
Fewest Offensive Plays
Most Touchdowns
Most PAT by Run or Pass
Most PAT by Run or Pass
Most PAT by Run or Pass

24
5
39
15
42
65
23
343
15
58
58
504
78
9
9
9
11
17
-125
12
129
74
834
7
10
48
5
7
59
27
328
19
40
77
41
6
2
2
2

first downs
first downs
first downs
first downs
attempts
attempts
completions
yards
yards
points
points
yards
yards
punts
punts
punts
kickoffs
punts
yards
penalties
plays
plays
yards
fumbles
turnovers
points
interceptions
points
carries
points
yards
points
yards
plays
plays
touchdowns
PATs
PATs
PATs

North
North
Game
Game
North
Game
North
South
North
Game
Game
South
South
North
South
North
South
Game
South
North
Game
South
Game
North
South
North
North
Game
North
North
North
North
South
North
South
North
South
South
South

2014
1987
2014
1992
2011
2013
2011
2013
2001
1989
2013
1995
1992
1987
2010
2017
2012
2017
1996
2017
2000
2000
2016
2002
1992
2012
1992
2010
2001
2012
2016
2015
2012
2010
2010
2012
1977
1995
2011